City of Hamilton
HAMILTON MUNICIPAL HERITAGE COMMITTEE
REVISED

Meeting #:

24-003

Date:

Friday, April 26, 2024

Time:

12:00 P.m. - 3:00 P.m.

Location:

Room 264, 2nd Floor, City Hall (hybrid) (RM)

71 Main Street West

Matt Gauthier, Legislative Coordinator [phone] ext. 6437

---

1.

CEREMONIAL ACTIVITIES

2.

APPROVAL OF AGENDA

(Added Items, if applicable, will be noted with *)

3.

DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST

4.

APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING

4.1

February 16, 2024

5.

COMMUNICATIONS

5.1

Correspondence respecting the Notice of Intention to Designate under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act, 84 York Boulevard, Hamilton (Philpot Memorial Church)

Recommendation: Be received. 

5.2

Correspondence from Jennifer Meader and Mark A. de Jong, TMA Law, on behalf of John Kemp, respecting Notice of Objection to Recommendation to List the Property on the Municipal Heritage Register

Recommendation: Be received and referred to the consideration of Item 10.2

6.

DELEGATION REQUESTS

6.1

Delegation Request from Matthew Hall and Madolyn Armstrong, Hamilton Conservation Authority, respecting Item 8.1 Report PED24057, Recommendation to Designate 2 Dartnall Road, Hamilton (Former Harris Grain Elevator), under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage 

Act (for today's meeting)

7.

DELEGATIONS

8.

STAFF PRESENTATIONS

8.1

Recommendation to Designate 2 Dartnall Road, Hamilton (Former Harris Grain Elevator), under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act (PED24057) (Ward 6)

9.

CONSENT ITEMS

9.1

Heritage Permit Review Sub-Committee Minutes

a.

December 12, 2023

b.

February 20, 2024 (Staff Liaison Report)

9.2

Education and Communications Working Group Meeting Notes - February 7, 2024

9.3

Policy and Design Working Group Meeting Notes - January 22, 2024

10.

DISCUSSION ITEMS

10.1

Demolition of 178 Wilson Street, Hamilton, Being a Non-Designated Property listed on the Municipal Heritage Register with an Unsafe Order to Comply (PED24081) (Ward 2)

10.2

Monthly Report on Proactive Listings for the Municipal Heritage Register, April 2024 (PED24058) (Wards 3 and 14)

10.3

Cross-Melville Heritage District Committee Report 24-001 (February 8, 2024)

10.4

Community Heritage Ontario Membership Renewal

10.5

Selecting Members to Attend 2024 Ontario Heritage Conference (no copy)

11.

MOTIONS

12.

NOTICES OF MOTION

13.

GENERAL INFORMATION / OTHER BUSINESS

13.1

Buildings and Landscapes

This list is determined by members of the Hamilton Municipal Heritage Committee. Members provide informal updates to the properties on this list, based on their visual assessments of the properties, or information they have gleaned from other sources, such as new articles and updates from other heritage groups.

Heritage Status:  (I) Inventoried, (R) Registered, (D) Designated, (NHS) National Historic Site 

a.

Endangered Buildings and Landscapes (RED)

Red = Properties where there is a perceived immediate threat to heritage resources through: demolition; neglect; vacancy; alterations, and/or, redevelopment)     

 

Ancaster

(1)       372 Butter Road West, Andrew Sloss House (D) – S. Spolnik

(2)       1021 Garner Road East, Lampman House (D) – S. Spolnik

(3)       398 Wilson Street East, Marr House (D) – S. Spolnik

 

Dundas

(4)       2 Hatt Street (R) – K. Burke

(5)       216 Hatt Street (I) – K. Burke

(6)       215 King Street West (R) – K. Burke

(7)       219 King Street West (R) – K. Burke

 

Glanbrook

(8)     2235 Upper James Street (R) – G. Carroll

 

Hamilton

(9)       80-92 Barton Street East, Former Hanrahan Hotel (R) – S. Spolnik

(10)     1155-1157 Beach Boulevard, Beach Canal Lighthouse and Cottage (D) – A. Denham-Robinson

(11)     66-68 Charlton Avenue West (D) – C. Kroetsch

(12)     71 Claremont Drive, Auchmar Gate House / Claremont Lodge (R) – G. Carroll

(13)     711 Concession Street, Former Mount Hamilton Hospital, 1932 Wing (R) – G. Carroll

(14)     127 Hughson Street North, Firth Brothers Building (D) – C. Kroetsch

(15)     163 Jackson Street West, Pinehurst / Television City (D) – C. Kroetsch

(16)     108 James Street North, Tivoli (D) – C. Kroetsch

(17)     98 James Street South, Former James Street Baptist Church (D) – C. Kroetsch

(18)     18-22 King Street East, Gore Buildings (D) – C. Kroetsch

(19)     24-28 King Street East, Gore Buildings (D) – C. Kroetsch

(20)     537 King Street East, Rebel’s Rock (R) – G. Carroll

(21)     378 Main Street East, Cathedral Boys School (R) – S. Spolnik

(22)     679 Main Street East / 85 Holton Street South, Former St. Giles Church (I) – G. Carroll

(23)     120 Park Street North (R) – C. Kroetsch

(24)     828 Sanatorium Road, Long and Bisby Building (D) – G. Carroll

(25)     100 West 5th Street, Century Manor (D) – G. Carroll

b.

Buildings and Landscapes of Interest (YELLOW)

(Yellow = Properties that are undergoing some type of change, such as a change in ownership or use, but are not perceived as being immediately threatened)

 

Dundas

(1)       64 Hatt Street, Former Valley City Manufacturing (D) – K. Burke

(2)       24 King Street West, Former Majestic Theatre (I) – K. Burke

(3)       3 Main Street, Former Masonic Lodge (D) – K. Burke

(4)       23 Melville Street, Knox Presbyterian Church (D) – K. Burke

(5)       574 Northcliffe Avenue, St. Joseph’s Motherhouse (R) – L. Lunsted

 

Flamborough

(6)       283 Brock Road, WF Township Hall (D) – L. Lunsted

(7)       62 6th Concession East, Hewick House (I) – L. Lunsted

 

Hamilton

(8)       1 Balfour Drive, Chedoke Estate / Balfour House, (R) – G. Carroll

(9)       134 Cannon Street East, Cannon Knitting Mill (R) – C. Kroetsch

(10)     52 Charlton Avenue West, Former Charlton Hall (D) – C. Kroetsch

(11)     2 Dartnall Road, Rymal Road Station Silos (R) – G. Carroll

(12)     54-56 Hess Street South (D) – C. Kroetsch

(13)     1284 Main Street East, Delta High School (D) – G. Carroll

(14)     311 Rymal Road East (R) – G. Carroll

(15)     St. Clair Boulevard Heritage Conservation District (D) – G. Carroll

(16)     56 York Boulevard / 63-76 MacNab Street North, Coppley Building (D) – G. Carroll

(17)     84 York Boulevard, Philpott Church (NOID) – G. Carroll

(18)     175 Lawrence Road, Hamilton Pressed / Century Brick (R) – G. Carroll

(19)     65 Charlton Avenue East, Church of Ascension (D, NHS), Hamilton – G. Carroll

(20)     4 Turner Avenue, Hamilton (R) – C. Kroetsch

(21)     420 King St E, St. Patrick Roman Catholic Church (I) – S. Spolnik

(22)     206-210 King Street East, Former Bremner Grocery (I) – G. Carroll

(23)     1269 Mohawk Road, Ancaster – G. Carroll

(24)     657 King Street East, Hamilton – G. Carroll

(25)     665-667 King Street East, Hamilton – G. Carroll

 

Stoney Creek

(26)     2251 Rymal Road East, Former Elfrida Church (R) – G. Carroll

c.

Heritage Properties Update (GREEN)

(Green = Properties whose status is stable)

 

Dundas

(1)       104 King Street West, Former Post Office (R) – K. Burke

 

Hamilton

(2)       46 Forest Avenue, Rastrick House (D) – G. Carroll

(3)       88 Fennell Avenue West, Auchmar (D) – A. Douglas

(4)       125 King Street East, Norwich Apartments (R) – C. Kroetsch

(5)       206 Main Street West, Arlo House (R) – C. Kroetsch

(6)       50-54 Sanders Boulevard, Binkley Property (R) –  K. Burke

 

Flamborough

(7)       340 Dundas Street East, Eager House (R) – L. Lunsted

d.

Heritage Properties Update (BLACK)

(Black = Properties that HMHC have no control over and may be demolished)  

 

Ancaster

(1)       442, 450 and 452 Wilson Street East (R) – S. Spolnik

13.2

Hamilton Municipal Heritage Committee's Heritage Recognition Awards - June 13, 2024 (no copy)

13.3

Update on the Hamilton Wentworth Heritage Association's 2024 Heritage Volunteer Recognition Awards held on April 20, 2024

13.4

Update on Doors Open Hamilton - May 4 and 5, 2024 (no copy)

14.

PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL 

15.

ADJOURNMENT