City of HamiltonPLANNING COMMITTEE REVISED AGENDAMeeting #:24-003Date:Friday, February 23, 2024Time: 9:30 A.m. - 10:30 A.m.Location:Council Chambers (Planning)Hamilton City Hall71 Main Street WestLisa Kelsey, Legislative Coordinator (905) 546-2424 ext. 46051.CEREMONIAL ACTIVITIES 2.APPROVAL OF AGENDA (Added Items, if applicable, will be noted with *)3.DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST 4.APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING 4.1February 6, 2024 1.PC Minutes 24-002 February 6, 2024.pdf5.COMMUNICATIONS 5.1Correspondence from Hamilton Urban Precinct Entertainment Group (HUPEG) respecting proposed Redevelopment of Philpott Memorial Church, located at 84 York Boulevard 1.5.1 HUPEG Letter of Support_84 York_Jan25-24.pdfRecommendation: Be received and referred to the consideration of Item 11.3. 6.DELEGATION REQUESTS 6.1Delegations respecting 84 York Blvd. (Item 11.3 ) (For today's meeting) (i) Malcolm Sears, Building Committee of Philpott Church (in-person)(ii) Stephen Armstrong, Armstrong Planning and Project Management (in-person)7.DELEGATIONS 8.STAFF PRESENTATIONS 9.CONSENT ITEMS 9.1Active Official Plan Amendment, Zoning By-law Amendment, and Plan of Subdivision Applications (PED24040) (City Wide) 1.PED24040.pdf2.PED24040 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24040 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24040 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24040 Appendix D.pdf10.PUBLIC HEARINGS 10.1Applications for Zoning By-law Amendment and Draft Plan of Subdivision for Lands Located at 26 Southcote Road, Ancaster (Ward 12) (PED24027) 1.PED24027.pdf2.PED24027 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24027 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24027 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24027 Appendix D.pdf6.PED24027 Appendix E.pdf7.PED24027 Appendix F.pdf8.PED24027 Appendix G.pdf9.PED24027 Appendix H.pdf10.PED24027 Appendix I.pdf11.PED24027 Appendix J.pdfa.Added Written Submissions: 1.10.1 (i) Dave Vidal_Redacted.pdf2.10.1 (ii) Bob and Carol Whitelaw_Redacted.pdf3.10.1 (iii) Anna-Marie Emili_Redacted.pdf(i) Dave Vidal and Mari McIntyre(ii) Bob and Carol Whitelaw(iii) Anna-Marie Emilib.Staff Presentation 1.PED24027 - Michael Fiorino Alaina Baldassarra.pdf10.2Application for Zoning By-law Amendment for Lands Located at 237 Springbrook Avenue, Ancaster (PED24042) (Ward 12) 1.PED24042.pdf2.PED24042 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24042 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24042 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24042 Appendix D.pdf6.PED24042 Appendix E.pdf7.PED24042 Appendix F.pdf8.PED24042 Appendix G.pdfa.Added Written Submissions: 1.10.2 (i) Emad Boles.pdf2.10.2 (ii) Firas and Stephanie Chahine_Redacted.pdf(i) Emad Boles(ii) Firas and Stephanie Chahineb.Staff Presentation 1.PED24042 - Daniel Barnett.pdf10.3Application for a Zoning By-law Amendment for Lands Located at 64 Hatt Street, Dundas (PED23164) (Ward 13) 1.PED23164.pdf2.10.3 PED23164 Appendix A.pdf3.10.3 PED23164 Appendix B R.pdf4.10.3 PED23164 Appendix C.pdf5.10.3 PED23164 Appendix D.pdf(Deferred from the November 14, 2023 meeting) (Revised Appendix "B")a.Added Written Submissions: 1.10.3 a i Anita Lauinger.pdf2.10.3 a ii Hamilton Conservation Authority.pdf(i) Anita Lauinger(ii) Mike Stone, Hamilton Conservation Authority10.4Updates and Amendments to the Low Density Residential (R1) and Low Density Residential (R1a) Zones, and Creation of a New Low Density Residential 1.PED22154(a).pdf2.PED22154(a) Appendix A.pdf3.PED22154(a) Appendix B.pdf4.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule A.pdf5.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule A Addendum.pdf6.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule B.pdf7.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule C.pdf8.PED22154(a) Appendix C Revised.pdf9.PED22154(a) Appendix D.pdf10.PED22154(a) Appendix D Schedule A.pdf11.PED22154(a) Appendix D Schedule B.pdf12.PED22154(a) Appendix E.pdf13.PED22154(a) Appendix F.pdf14.PED22154(a) Appendix G.pdf15.PED22154(a) Appendix H.pdfLarge Lot (R2) Zone, Creation of a New Section 5: Parking, and Technical Amendments to Zoning By-law No. 05-200 as Phase 2 of the Residential Zones Project (PED22154(a)) (City Wide) (Outstanding Business List Item)*Revised Appendix "B" Schedule "A" Addendum*Revised Appendix "C"a.Registered Delegations: (i) Brian Sibley, Hamilton East Kiwanis Non-Profit Homes Inc. (in-person)(ii) Michelle Diplock, West End Home Builders' Association (in-person)a.Added Registered Delegations: (iii) Glenn Davies (in-person)(iv) Chris Ritsma (in-person)(v) Anna-Marie Emili (virtual)(vi) Adeola Egbeyemi, Environment Hamilton (in-person)b.Written Submissions: 1.10.4 b (i) Patricia and Leslie Matthews_Redacted.pdf2.10.4 b (ii) Tilda Bodo_Redacted.pdf(i) Patricia and Leslie Matthews(ii) Tilda Bodoa.Added Written Submissions: 1.10.4 Added Written Submissions (iii - xviii).pdf2.10.4 (xix) Kaitlin Webber, MHBC Planning.pdf3.10.4 (xx) Matt Johnston, Urban Solutions.pdf4.10.4 (xxi) Ed Scharringa and Jon Bos, Christian Farmers Federation of Ontario (CFFO).pdf5.10.4 (xxii) Howard Cole.pdf6.10.4 (xxiii) Stephanie Mirtitsch, MHBC Planning.pdf7.10.4 (xxiv) Fernando Puga, DeSantis Homes.pdf8.10.4 (xxv) Fernando Puga, Winona Point Joint Venture Inc.pdf(iii) Margaret Tremblay(iv) Paul O'Hara(v) Brian McHattie(vi) Jason Allen(vii) Brian Allore(viii) Shania Ramharrack-Maharaj(ix) Peter Appleton(x) Emil Gadjanski(xi) Marie Covert(xii) Dawn Cole(xiii) Gord & Angie McNulty(xiv) Jill Tonini(xv) Anne Bell, Ontario Nature(xvi) Chris Ritsma(xvii) Jan Bard(xviii) Richard MacKinnon & Sonia MacKinnon(xix) Kaitlin Webber, MHBC Planning(xx) Matt Johnston, Urban Solutions(xxi) Ed Scharringa and Jon Bos, Christian Farmers Federation of Ontario (CFFO)(xxi) Howard Cole(xxiii) Stephanie Mirtitsch, MHBC Planning(xxiv) Fernando Puga, DeSantis Homes(xxv) Fernando Puga, Winona Point Joint Venture Incc.Revised Appendix "B" Schedule "A" Addendum and Revised Appendix "C" (attached to Item 10.4) d.Staff Presentation 1.PED22154(a) - Alana Fulford.pdf11.DISCUSSION ITEMS 11.1Request for Direction to Proceed with Appeal of Committee of Adjustment Decision to Approve Consent Application FL/B-20:01 and Minor Variance Application FL/A-20:04, for Lands Located at 177 Highway 8, Flamborough (PED24043) (Ward 13) 1.PED24043.pdf2.PED24043 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24043 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24043 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24043 Appendix D.pdf6.PED24043 Appendix E - 177 Hwy 8 Consent Redacted.pdf7.PED24043 Appendix F - 177 Hwy 8 Minor Variance Redacted.pdfa.Staff Presentation 1.PED24043 - Joe Buordolone.pdf11.2Request for Direction to Proceed with Appeal of Committee of Adjustment Decision to Approve Consent Application FL/B-23:73 for Lands Located at 2050 Centre Road, Flamborough (PED24045) (Ward 15) 1.PED24045.pdf2.PED24045 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24045 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24045 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24045 Appendix D - 2050 Centre Road Application.pdfa.Staff Presentation 1.PED24045 - Joe Buordolone.pdf11.3Hamilton Municipal Heritage Committee Report 24-001 1.HMHC Report 24-001 January 26 2024.pdf2.HMHC Report 24-001 Appendix A to Item 3.pdfa.Staff Presentation 1.11.3 Staff Presentation 84 York Boulevard_Planning Committee.pdf11.4To Amend Zoning By-law No. 05-200 with Respect to Farm Labour Residences and Additional Dwelling Units - Detached in Rural Areas (PED22002(b)) (Wards 9, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 15) 1.PED22002(a) Signed Report Amended.pdf2.PED22002(a) Appendix A - Amended.pdf3.PED22002(a) Appendix B - Amended Revision.pdf(Deferred from the February 6th meeting)*Revised Staff Report, Appendix "A" and "B"a.Revised Staff Report, Appendix "A and "B" (attached to Item 11.4) 11.5Hamilton Municipal Heritage Committee Report 24-002 1.HMHC Report 24-002 February 16 2024.pdf2.HMHC Report 24-002 Appendix A to Item 1.pdf12.MOTIONS 12.1Demolition Permit for 9423, 9517, 9569, 9579, 9867 Dickenson Road West and 1205 Glancaster Road 1.12.1 Demolition Permit for 9423, 9517, 9569, 9579, 9867 Dickenson Road West and 1205 Glancaster Road.pdf12.2City Initiated Housekeeping to recognize the existing Commercial Parking Facility at 221 York Boulevard, Hamilton 1.12.2 City Initiated Housekeeping to Recognize Existing Commercial Parking at 221 York Blvd.pdf12.3Issuance of a Demolition Permit for 66 Wellington St. North (Ward 3) 1.12.3 Revised Motion - 66 Wellington St. N.pdf* Revised Motiona.Revised Motion (attached to 12.3) 13.NOTICES OF MOTION 14.GENERAL INFORMATION / OTHER BUSINESS 15.PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL 15.1Closed Session Minutes - February 6, 2024 Public Comments: Pursuant to Section 9.3, Sub-sections (e), (f) and (k) of the City's Procedural By-law 21-021, as amended; and, Section 239(2), Subsections (e), (f) and (k) of the Ontario Municipal Act, 2001, as amended, as the subject matter pertains to litigation or potential litigation, including matters before administrative tribunals, affecting the municipality or local board; advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege, including communications necessary for that purpose; and, a position, plan, procedure, criteria or instruction to be applied to any negotiations carried on or to be carried on by or on behalf of the municipality or local board.15.2Appeal to the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) for lands located at 651 Queenston Road, Hamilton, for Lack of Decision on Urban Hamilton Official Plan Amendment Application (UHOPA-22-009) Public Comments: and Zoning By-law Amendment Application (ZAC-22-018) (LS23001(a)) (Ward 5) Pursuant to Section 9.3, Sub-sections (e), (f) and (k) of the City's Procedural By-law 21-021, as amended; and, Section 239(2), Subsections (e), (f) and (k) of the Ontario Municipal Act, 2001, as amended, as the subject matter pertains to litigation or potential litigation, including matters before administrative tribunals, affecting the municipality or local board; advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege, including communications necessary for that purpose; and, a position, plan, procedure, criteria or instruction to be applied to any negotiations carried on or to be carried on by or on behalf of the municipality or local board.15.3Appeal to the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) for Lands Located at 801, 820, 828, 855, 865 and 870 Scenic Drive and 828 Sanatorium Road, Hamilton, Public Comments: for Lack of Decision on Urban Hamilton Official Plan Amendment Application (UHOPA-20-026), Zoning By-law Amendment Application (ZAC-20-041) and Draft Plan of Subdivision Application (25T-202008) (LS22005(a)) (Ward 14) Pursuant to Section 9.3, Sub-sections (e), (f) and (k) of the City's Procedural By-law 21-021, as amended; and, Section 239(2), Subsections (e), (f) and (k) of the Ontario Municipal Act, 2001, as amended, as the subject matter pertains to litigation or potential litigation, including matters before administrative tribunals, affecting the municipality or local board; advice that is subject to solicitor-client privilege, including communications necessary for that purpose; and, a position, plan, procedure, criteria or instruction to be applied to any negotiations carried on or to be carried on by or on behalf of the municipality or local board.16.ADJOURNMENT No Item Selected This item has no attachments.1.PED24040.pdf2.PED24040 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24040 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24040 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24040 Appendix D.pdf1.PED24027.pdf2.PED24027 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24027 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24027 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24027 Appendix D.pdf6.PED24027 Appendix E.pdf7.PED24027 Appendix F.pdf8.PED24027 Appendix G.pdf9.PED24027 Appendix H.pdf10.PED24027 Appendix I.pdf11.PED24027 Appendix J.pdf1.PED24042.pdf2.PED24042 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24042 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24042 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24042 Appendix D.pdf6.PED24042 Appendix E.pdf7.PED24042 Appendix F.pdf8.PED24042 Appendix G.pdf1.HMHC Report 24-001 January 26 2024.pdf2.HMHC Report 24-001 Appendix A to Item 3.pdf1.5.1 HUPEG Letter of Support_84 York_Jan25-24.pdf1.PC Minutes 24-002 February 6, 2024.pdf1.PED24043.pdf2.PED24043 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24043 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24043 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24043 Appendix D.pdf6.PED24043 Appendix E - 177 Hwy 8 Consent Redacted.pdf7.PED24043 Appendix F - 177 Hwy 8 Minor Variance Redacted.pdf1.PED24045.pdf2.PED24045 Appendix A.pdf3.PED24045 Appendix B.pdf4.PED24045 Appendix C.pdf5.PED24045 Appendix D - 2050 Centre Road Application.pdf1.PED23164.pdf2.10.3 PED23164 Appendix A.pdf3.10.3 PED23164 Appendix B R.pdf4.10.3 PED23164 Appendix C.pdf5.10.3 PED23164 Appendix D.pdf1.12.2 City Initiated Housekeeping to Recognize Existing Commercial Parking at 221 York Blvd.pdf1.PED22154(a).pdf2.PED22154(a) Appendix A.pdf3.PED22154(a) Appendix B.pdf4.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule A.pdf5.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule A Addendum.pdf6.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule B.pdf7.PED22154(a) Appendix B Schedule C.pdf8.PED22154(a) Appendix C Revised.pdf9.PED22154(a) Appendix D.pdf10.PED22154(a) Appendix D Schedule A.pdf11.PED22154(a) Appendix D Schedule B.pdf12.PED22154(a) Appendix E.pdf13.PED22154(a) Appendix F.pdf14.PED22154(a) Appendix G.pdf15.PED22154(a) Appendix H.pdf1.12.1 Demolition Permit for 9423, 9517, 9569, 9579, 9867 Dickenson Road West and 1205 Glancaster Road.pdf1.10.4 b (i) Patricia and Leslie Matthews_Redacted.pdf2.10.4 b (ii) Tilda Bodo_Redacted.pdf1.HMHC Report 24-002 February 16 2024.pdf2.HMHC Report 24-002 Appendix A to Item 1.pdf1.10.2 (i) Emad Boles.pdf2.10.2 (ii) Firas and Stephanie Chahine_Redacted.pdf1.12.3 Revised Motion - 66 Wellington St. N.pdf1.PED22002(a) Signed Report Amended.pdf2.PED22002(a) Appendix A - Amended.pdf3.PED22002(a) Appendix B - Amended Revision.pdf1.10.3 a i Anita Lauinger.pdf2.10.3 a ii Hamilton Conservation Authority.pdf1.10.1 (i) Dave Vidal_Redacted.pdf2.10.1 (ii) Bob and Carol Whitelaw_Redacted.pdf3.10.1 (iii) Anna-Marie Emili_Redacted.pdf1.10.4 Added Written Submissions (iii - xviii).pdf2.10.4 (xix) Kaitlin Webber, MHBC Planning.pdf3.10.4 (xx) Matt Johnston, Urban Solutions.pdf4.10.4 (xxi) Ed Scharringa and Jon Bos, Christian Farmers Federation of Ontario (CFFO).pdf5.10.4 (xxii) Howard Cole.pdf6.10.4 (xxiii) Stephanie Mirtitsch, MHBC Planning.pdf7.10.4 (xxiv) Fernando Puga, DeSantis Homes.pdf8.10.4 (xxv) Fernando Puga, Winona Point Joint Venture Inc.pdf1.PED22154(a) - Alana Fulford.pdf1.PED24027 - Michael Fiorino Alaina Baldassarra.pdf1.PED24042 - Daniel Barnett.pdf1.PED24043 - Joe Buordolone.pdf1.PED24045 - Joe Buordolone.pdf1.11.3 Staff Presentation 84 York Boulevard_Planning Committee.pdf