INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SUB-COMMITTEEAGENDA 821 JUNE 2010 SOUS-COMITÉ DE LA TECHNOLOGIE DE L’INFORMATIONORDRE DU JOUR 8LE 21 JUIN 2010 City of Hamilton GENERAL ISSUES COMMITTEE March 28, 2017, 9:30 AM Council Chambers, Hamilton City Hall, 71 Main Street West Stephanie Paparella, Legislative Coordinator 905 546-2424 x3993 1. CHANGES TO THE AGENDA (Added Items, if applicable, will be noted with **) 2. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST 3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING 4. DELEGATION REQUESTS 4.1 Brian Smiley, Patient Advocate, respecting Accessibility Issues for the Elderly, Disabled, etc. in relation to the LRT and its Negative Impact on their Lives 4.2 Attilio Di Fiore, B.Sc., B.Sc.Eng., P.Eng., President and CSO of ATTWILL Medical Solutions Inc., respecting Valid Reasoning from an Engineering Perspective why the Hamilton LRT is a Flawed Plan and is Not a Viable Option for Improving Hamilton’s Transit System 4.3 Cole Raftery, Raftery Law, respecting the Legalities related to the LRT 4.4 Milena Balta, respecting LRT 4.5 Ron Johnson, Constituent – senior resident in Ward 3 for 42 Years, respecting concerns and issues pertaining to the LRT 4.6 Sarah Warry Poljanski, Constituent and Hydro Activits, respecting concerns and issues pertaining to the LRT and its relation to Hydro 4.7 Keanin Loomis, Hamilton Chamber of Commerce, respecting Item 8.2 – Bay Street Stop 4.8 Ryan McGreal, Hamilton Light Rail, respecting the LRT Environmental Assessment amendment 4.9 Tanya Ritchie, Hamilton Guesthouse, respecting the proposed LRT project in Hamilton, specifically the Environmental Project Report 4.10 Lee Edward Mcllmoyle, respecting the current and future needs of disabled persons on the projected LRT routes 4.11 Paul Wright, IT specialist, respecting the concerns related to the proposed LRT 4.12 Chris Parkinson, respecting a review of LRT EA and to discuss how council is working within the Right to a Healthy Environment motion passed Feb. 2015 4.13 Phil Ryerson, respecting the LRT 4.14 Veroslav (Vic) Djurdjevic, Nikola Tesla Education Corporation (NTEC), respecting the LRT proposal 4.15 Graham Jeffries, respecting LRT 4.16 Franco Corti, Constituent of Ward 1, respecting LRT (for March 28, 2017 4.17 Benita van Miltenburg, Cycle Hamilton, respecting support for a Bay St. LRT stop and the LRT project 4.18 Nicholas Kevlahan, respecting support for Hamilton’s LRT project and urge speedy approval of the revised environmental assessment 4.19 Patrick Rose, respecting LRT 4.20 Alain H. Bureau & Mark Rejhon, Hamilton LRT Advocacy, respecting local support for the Hamilton LRT project 4.21 Katy Yelovich, Ward 1 Constituent, respecting concerns pertaining to LRT 4.22 Johanna Bleecker, Cycle Hamilton, respecting support for LRT and Bay Street Bike Lanes 4.23 Karl Andrus, Stinson Community Association, respecting the environmental assessment for Hamilton LRT project 4.24 Matthew Carrabs & Doug Caldwell, Yes to LRT in Hamilton, respecting LRT 4.25 John Wilbur, respecting LRT 4.26 Graham McNally, Toms + McNally Design, respecting support for the LRT project 4.27 Dr. Lynda Lukasik, Environment Hamilton, respecting LRT 4.28 David Premi, DPAI Architecture, respecting support for LRT environmental Report 4.29 Anna Davey, Women’s March Hamilton, respecting LRT 4.30 Dale MacNevin, respecting LRT 4.31 Suzanne Mammel, HHHBA, respecting LRT 4.32 Sandi Stride, Sustainable Hamilton Burlington, respecting support for the LRT in Hamilton for the long-term health and prosperity of the City 4.33 Frank Lechlither, respecting LRT 4.34 Malcolm Hodgskiss, respecting LRT 4.35 Gaspare Bonomo respecting LRT 4.36 Ken Watson respecting LRT 5. CONSENT ITEMS 6. PUBLIC HEARINGS / DELEGATIONS 6.1 Ellen Morris, respecting the LRT Stop at Bay Street 6.2 Carol Lazich, Hamilton C.O.S.T., respecting the Proposed LRT 6.3 Cheryl St. James, Weird Stuff Retail Store, respecting the Proposed LRT and its Impacts on Businesses 6.4 Cameron Bailey, Former Hamilton Resident and Business Owner, respecting the Proposed LRT and the Negative Impact of the Bus Lane 6.5 John McGreal, Concerns related to the LRT Project 6.6 Dr. Paul O’Byrne, Dean and Vice President, Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University 7. PRESENTATIONS 7.1 Hamilton Light Rail Transit (LRT) Environmental Project Report (EPR) Addendum for B-Line (PED17056) (City Wide) (a Written submissions respecting Hamilton Light Rail Transit (LRT) Environmental Project Report (EPR) Addendum for B-Line (PED17056) (City Wide): Recommendation: Be received and referred to the consideration of Item 7.1 Hamilton Light Rail Transit (LRT) Environmental Project Report (EPR) Addendum for B-Line (PED17056) (City Wide). Anne Chaffee Carolyn Kinsley 7.2 Proposed A-Line Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Update (PED17048) (City Wide) (a Written Submission respecting the Proposed A-Line Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Update (PED17048) (City Wide) Recommendation: Be received and referred to the consideration of Item 7.2 Proposed A-Line Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) Update (PED17048) (City Wide). Agnes Frebold 7.3 Hamilton Light Rail Transit (LRT) Community Benefits Overview (PED17058) (City Wide) 8. DISCUSSION ITEMS 8.1 Light Rail Transit (LRT) Procurement Model (PED17030) (City Wide) 8.2 Bay Street Stop Assessment (PED17021) (City Wide) (a Written submissions respecting the Bay Street Stop Assessment (PED17021) (City Wide): Recommendation: Be received and referred to the consideration of Item 8.2 Bay Street Stop Assessment (PED17021) (City Wide). John McGreal Mike Majcher Barb Allen Ameriga Alonzo and Douglas Alonzo-Ortiz Huzaifa Saeed Graeme Luke Jason Morse Kathryn Deiter W.T. (Bill) Elliot Erin Snajdman-Griver David Jenkins Dave Gava Lee Purins Patrick Rose Evan Pray Marie Zilik Kass Forman Gregoire Gagnon on behalf of the Hamilton Philharmonic Youth Orchestra Ellen Morris Paul Seczek Lachlan Holmes John Morris Ann McKay Adrian Duyzer Tyler Pearson Nicholas Kevlahan Kevin Love Dave Heidebrecht Ryan McGreal Daniel Lynes W.T. (Bill) Elliot Keanin Loomis David Colacci 9. MOTIONS 9.1 Cost Implications to Hamilton Taxpayers Should Council Discontinue the Light Rail Transit Project 9.2 Cost Implications specific to any Potential Bidders’ Claims, should Council decide to Discontinue the Light Rail Transit Project 9.3 Review of the Provincial Processes, as they relate to Light Rail Transit 9.4 Butternut Tree Conservation 10. NOTICES OF MOTION 11. GENERAL INFORMATION / OTHER BUSINESS 12. PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL 13. ADJOURNMENT No Item Selected This item has no attachments1.Brian Smiley Patient Advocate respecting Accessi - 4.1 Delegation Request - Brian Smiley.pdf1.Attilio Di Fiore B.Sc. B.Sc.Eng. P.Eng. Presid - 4.2 Delegation Request - Atillio Di Fiore.pdf1.Cole Raftery Raftery Law respecting the Legaliti - 4.3 Delegation Request - Cole Raftery.pdf1.Milena Balta respecting LRT - 4.4 Delegation Request - Milena Balta.pdf2.Milena Balta respecting LRT - 4.4 Milena Balta.pdf1.Carol Lazich Hamilton C.O.S.T. respecting the Pr - 6.2 Carol Lazich COST Hamilton.pdf1.Proposed A-Line Bus Rapid Transit BRT Update PE - 7.2 PED17048.pdf2.Proposed A-Line Bus Rapid Transit BRT Update PE - 7.2 PED17048 - Appendix A.pdf3.Proposed A-Line Bus Rapid Transit BRT Update PE - 7.2 PED17048 - Presentation.pdf1.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Community Benefi - 7.3 PED17058.pdf2.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Community Benefi - 7.3 PED17058 - Presentation.pdf1.Light Rail Transit LRT Procurement Model PED170 - 8.1 PED17030.pdf2.Light Rail Transit LRT Procurement Model PED170 - 8.1 PED17030 - Appendix A.pdf1.Bay Street Stop Assessment PED17021 City Wide - 8.2 PED17021.pdf1.Cost Implications to Hamilton Taxpayers Should Cou - 9.1 Motion - Cost to Discontinue LRT Merulla.pdf1.Cost Implications specific to any Potential Bidder - 9.2 Motion - Costs Specific to Bidders is City Discontinues LRT.pdf1.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 PED17056.pdf2.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT 2017 Environmental Project Report EPR Addendum.pdf3.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix A_City of Hamilton 2011 B-Line LRT EPR.pdf4.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix B_Design Plates and Cross-sections.pdf5.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-1_Hydrogeology Report.pdf6.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-2_Contamination Overview Study.pdf7.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-3_Part 1_Ecology Report.pdf8.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-3_Part 2_Ecology Report.pdf9.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-3_Part 3_Ecology Report.pdf10.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-3_Part 4_Ecology Report.pdf11.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-4_Arborist Memo Endangered Species.pdf12.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-5_Part 1_Supplemental Tree Inventory.pdf13.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-5_Part 2_Supplemental Tree Inventory.pdf14.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-5_Part 3_Supplemental Tree Inventory.pdf15.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix C-5_Part 4_Supplemental Tree Inventory.pdf16.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-6_Air Quality Existing Conditions and Air Quality Study.pdf17.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-7_Stormwater Management Report.pdf18.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-8_Review of B-Line Geotechnical Report.pdf19.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-9_Noise and Vibration Study.pdf20.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-10_Stage 1 Archaeological Assessment Report.pdf21.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-11_Volume 1_Cultural Heritage Screening Report.pdf22.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-11_Volume 2_Gap Analysis.pdf23.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-11_Volume 3_CHERS_Part 1 of 4.pdf24.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-11_Volume 3_CHERS_Part 2 of 4.pdf25.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-11_Volume 3_CHERS_Part 3 of 4.pdf26.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix C-11_Volume 3_CHERS_Part 4 of 4.pdf27.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-1_Part 1_Hamilton LRT PIC 1 Consultation Appendix.pdf28.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-1_Part 2_Hamilton LRT PIC 1 Consultation Appendix.pdf29.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-1_Part 3_Hamilton LRT PIC 1 Consultation Appendix.pdf30.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-1_Part 4_Hamilton LRT PIC 1 Consultation Appendix.pdf31.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-2_Part 1_Hamilton LRT PIC 2 Consultation Appendix.pdf32.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-2_Part 2_Hamilton LRT PIC 2 Consultation Appendix.pdf33.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-2_Part 3_Hamilton LRT PIC 2 Consultation Appendix.pdf34.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - Appendix D-2_Part 4_Hamilton LRT PIC 2 Consultation Appendix.pdf35.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix D-3_Aboriginal Consultation Record.pdf36.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix D-4_Record of Circulation of Draft EPR Comments and Responses.pdf37.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix D-5_Public Consultation Record.pdf38.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix E-1_EMME Ridership Forecasting Report.pdf39.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix E-2_Wider Area Impacts Report.pdf40.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix E-3_VISSIM Modelling Report.pdf41.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Appendix F_High-Order Pedestrian Connection.pdf42.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 PED17056 - Presentation.pdf43.Hamilton Light Rail Transit LRT Environmental Pr - 7.1 Summers Lane to Hughson Map.pdf1.Ron Johnson Constituent senior resident in Ward - 4.5 Delegation Request - Ron Johnson.pdf2.Ron Johnson Constituent senior resident in Ward - 4.5 Ron Johnson.pdf1.Sarah Warry Poljanski Constituent and Hydro Activ - 4.6 Delegation Request - Sarah Warry Poljanski.pdf1.Keanin Loomis Hamilton Chamber of Commerce respe - 4.7 Delegation Request - Keanin Loomis.pdf2.Keanin Loomis Hamilton Chamber of Commerce respe - 4.7 Keanin Loomis Hamilton Chamber of Commerce.pdf1.Ryan McGreal Hamilton Light Rail respecting the - 4.8 Delegation Request - Ryan McGreal.pdf1.Tanya Ritchie Hamilton Guesthouse respecting the - 4.9 Delegation Request - Tanya Ritchie.pdf1.Lee Edward Mcllmoyle respecting the current and f - 4.10 Delegation Request - Lee Edward Mcllmoyle.pdf1.Paul Wright IT specialist respecting the concern - 4.11 Delegation Request - Paul Wright.pdf1.Chris Parkinson respecting a review of LRT EA and - 4.12 Delegation Request - Chris Parkinson.pdf1.Phil Ryerson respecting the LRT - 4.13 Delegation Request - Phil Ryerson.pdf2.Phil Ryerson respecting the LRT - 4.13 Phil Ryerson.pdf1.Veroslav Vic Djurdjevic Nikola Tesla Education - 4.14 Delegation Request - Veroslav Vic Djurdjevic.pdf1.Graham Jeffries respecting LRT - 4.15 Delegation Request - Graham Jeffries.pdf1.Franco Corti Constituent of Ward 1 respecting LR - 4.16 Delegation Request - Franco Corti.pdf1.Benita van Miltenburg Cycle Hamilton respecting - 4.17 Delegation Request - Benita van Miltenburg.pdf1.Nicholas Kevlahan respecting support for Hamilton - 4.18 Delegation Request - Nicholas Kevlahan.pdf1.Patrick Rose respecting LRT - 4.19 Delegation Request - Patrick Rose.pdf1.Alain H. Bureau Mark Rejhon Hamilton LRT Advoca - 4.20 Delegation Request - Alain H Bureau Mark Rejohn.pdf2.Alain H. Bureau Mark Rejhon Hamilton LRT Advoca - 4.20 Alain Bureau and Mark Rejhon.pdf1.Katy Yelovich Ward 1 Constituent respecting conc - 4.21 Delegation Request - Katy Yelovich.pdf1.Johanna Bleecker Cycle Hamilton respecting suppo - 4.22 Delegation Request - Johanna Bleecker.pdf1.Karl Andrus Stinson Community Association respec - 4.23 Delegation Request - Karl Andrus.pdf2.Karl Andrus Stinson Community Association respec - 4.23 Karl Andrus.pdf1.Matthew Carrabs Doug Caldwell Yes to LRT in Ham - 4.24 Delegation Request - Matthew Carrabs Doug Caldwell.pdf2.Matthew Carrabs Doug Caldwell Yes to LRT in Ham - 4.24 Doug Caldwell.pdf1.John Wilbur respecting LRT - 4.25 Delegation Request -John Wilbur.pdf1.Graham McNally Toms McNally Design respecting - 4.26 Delegation Request - Graham McNally.pdf2.Graham McNally Toms McNally Design respecting - 4.26 Graham McNally.pdf1.Dr. Lynda Lukasik Environment Hamilton respectin - 4.27 Delegation Request - Lynda Lukasik.pdf1.David Premi DPAI Architecture respecting support - 4.28 Delegation Request - David Premi.pdf1.Anna Davey Womens March Hamilton respecting LRT - 4.29 Delegation Request - Anna Davey.pdf1.Dale MacNevin respecting LRT - 4.30 Delegation Request - Dale MacNevin.pdf1.Suzanne Mammel HHHBA respecting LRT - 4.31 Delegation Request - Suzanne Mammel.pdf1.Sandi Stride Sustainable Hamilton Burlington res - 4.32 Delegation Request - Sandi Stride.pdf2.Sandi Stride Sustainable Hamilton Burlington res - 4.32 Sandi Stride.pdf1.Frank Lechlither respecting LRT - 4.33 Delegation Request - Frank Lechlitner.pdf1.Malcolm Hodgskiss respecting LRT - 4.34 Delegation Request - Malcolm Hodgskiss.pdf2.Malcolm Hodgskiss respecting LRT - 4.34 Malcolm Hodgskiss.pdf1.Review of the Provincial Processes as they relate - 9 3 Motion - Accountability and Reporting - LRT Whitehead.pdf1.Butternut Tree Conservation - Motion - Butternut Tree Conservation A. Johnson.pdf1.Anne Chaffee - 7.1i Chaffee.pdf1.Carolyn Kinsley - 7.1ii Kinsley.pdf1.Agnes Frebold - 7. 2ii Frebold.pdf1.John McGreal - 8.2i McGreal.pdf1.Mike Majcher - 8.2ii Majcher.pdf1.Barb Allen - 8.2iii Allen.pdf1.Ameriga Alonzo and Douglas Alonzo-Ortiz - 8.2iv Alonzo.pdf1.Huzaifa Saeed - 8.2v Saeed.pdf1.Graeme Luke - 8.2vi Luke.pdf1.Jason Morse - 8.2vii Morse.pdf1.Kathryn Deiter - 8.2viii Kathryn Deiter.pdf1.W.T. Bill Elliot - 8.2ix Elliot.pdf1.Erin Snajdman-Griver - 8.2x Snajdman-Griver.pdf1.David Jenkins - 8.2xi Jenkins.pdf1.Dave Gava - 8.2xii Gava.pdf1.Lee Purins - 8.2xiii Lee Purins.pdf1.Patrick Rose - 8.2xiv Rose.pdf1.Evan Pray - 8.2xv Pray.pdf1.Marie Zilik - 8.2xvi Zilik.pdf1.Kass Forman - 8.2xvii Forman.pdf1.Gregoire Gagnon on behalf of the Hamilton Philharm - 8.2xviiiGagnon.pdf1.Ellen Morris - 8.2xix Morris.pdf1.Paul Seczek - 8.2xx Seczek.pdf1.Lachlan Holmes - 8.2xxi Holmes.pdf1.John Morris - 8.2xxii Morris.pdf1.Ann McKay - 8.2xxiii Ann McKay.pdf1.Adrian Duyzer - 8.2xxiv Duyzer.pdf1.Tyler Pearson - 8.2xxv Pearson.pdf1.Nicholas Kevlahan - 8.2 xxvi Kevlahan.pdf1.Kevin Love - 8.2xxvii Love.pdf1.Dave Heidebrecht - 8.2xxviii Heidebrecht.pdf1.Ryan McGreal - 8.2xxix McGreal.pdf1.Daniel Lynes - 8.2xxx Daniel Lynes.pdf1.W.T. Bill Elliot - 8.2xxxi Elliot.pdf1.Keanin Loomis - 8.2xxxii Loomis.pdf1.David Colacci - 8.2xxxiii Colacci.pdf1.Gaspare Bonomo respecting LRT - 4.35 Gaspare Bonomo 1.pdf2.Gaspare Bonomo respecting LRT - 4.35 Gaspare Bonomo 2.pdf3.Gaspare Bonomo respecting LRT - 4.35 Gaspare Bonomo 3.pdf4.Gaspare Bonomo respecting LRT - 4.35 Gaspare Bonomo 4.pdf1.Ken Watson respecting LRT - 4.36 Ken Watson.pdf